D H
Oct 13 · Last update 15 days ago.

Who is the real threat to free speech?

Despite being technologically better equipped to communicate than ever before the issue of freedom of speech remains more divided and more convoluted than ever before. Whether university campuses, social media platforms, in the media or at sporting events, “censorious lefties” are often accused of undermining free speech, therefore posing a threat to the foundations of modern liberal societies. Yet right wing populist politicians have carried out some of the worst cases of silencing actual free speech, freedom of expression or freedom of the press in recent years. Are the sources of anti-free speech trends being conflated or do these phenomenon exist simultaneously? Is there really a campus free speech issue at universities? Is the left trying to attack free speech or are proponents of free speech exaggerating the limits of what we are allowed to say? Or is this an increasingly out of touch attempt to hold on to hate speech? Who is the real threat to free speech?
Stats of Viewpoints
The right actually has the free speech problem
0 agrees
0 disagrees
Viewpoints
Add New Viewpoint

The right actually has the free speech problem

The issue of free speech is somewhat complicated with attacks on free speech coming from various sources, however the often-criticised university campuses are showing signs of improving, while other issues are not. In the United States 37 universities have no speech codes up from 8 in 2009, likewise 27 schools or faculty bodies have embraced free speech principles, and dis-invitation of controversial speakers on campus have similarly dropped in recent years from a peak in 2016. However, despite posing as the custodians of free speech, right-wing lawmakers have the real problem here, showing openness to use positions of state power to quash freedom of expression, whether that is a take a knee protest or publishing state secrets in the public interest.

This larger issue of censorship represents the biggest attack on freedom of the press in a generation, the persecution and punishment of Julian Assange being clearly unconstitutional but actively being carried out under the administration of a right-wing populist. Meanwhile, the matter is being convoluted by the much louder and more heavily covered story of wealthy celebrities being held to account by ordinary people online for their prejudice opinions, an issue being actively conflated with universities by anti-PC pundits and grifters eager to skew the picture. The right has generated a culture-war straw-man over the issue of free speech in academia, in order to avoid talking about policy issues and to groom a new generation of status-quo-defending conservative thinkers.

theweek.com/articles/863225/leftwing-threat-campus-free-speech-abating-rightwing-threat-not gq.com/story/free-speech-grifting slate.com/news-and-politics/2018/03/the-real-threats-to-free-speech-arent-campus-protests.html washingtonpost.com/outlook/2019/10/15/real-threat-free-speech-campus-isnt-coming-left

Agree
Disagree
Latest conversation
D H
Oct 13
Approved
DH edited this paragraph
This larger issue of censorship represents the biggest attack on freedom of the press in a generation, the persecution and punishment of Julian Assange being clearly unconstitutional but actively being carried out under the administration of a right-wing populist. Meanwhile, the matter is being convoluted by the much louder and more heavily covered story of wealthy celebrities being held to account by ordinary people online for their prejudice opinions, an issue being actively conflated with universities by anti-PC pundits and grifters eager to skew the picture. The right has generated a culture-war straw-man over the issue of free speech in academia, in order to avoid talking about policy issues and to groom a new generation of status-quo-defending conservative thinkers.
Translate